If you want to take your Christmas turkey to the next level, this buttermilk brine is a surefire way to do it!
The foolproof method to achieving a wonderfully succulent turkey every time, it’s so simple yet so incredibly effective. With just four ingredients, plus the option of my secret ingredient, you’ll end up with the best Christmas turkey ever!
Products you need for this recipe
There are a few items you’ll need to make this brine, as well as when using it to brine your turkey.
- Large saucepan – you’ll need either a large saucepan or a large stock pot to do the job
- Kosher salt – when it comes to brining your Christmas or Thanksgiving turkey, this salt is the best salt to use. It’s coarser than standard sea salt and is less salty, bringing a more subtle savory flavor
- Brining bags – a large brining bag is essential for this recipe
- Cooler box – if you haven’t got the refrigerator space, get yourself a cooler box
Buttermilk brine recipe
This brine is so simple. With only four ingredients, most of this recipe is about having patience and allowing the brine to do its thing.
The ingredients list is water, buttermilk, kosher salt and brown sugar… simple!
However, there’s a spicy little twist to this brine turkey tale… the addition of an optional ‘secret’ ingredient, that promises to take your brined turkey to a whole new level.
What’s the secret ingredient to this brine?
Well, it’s one of America’s favorite spice blends. A heady concoction of at least 16 different herbs and spices, that brings a unique flavor to any dish it’s used with.
Old Bay Seasoning brings such character and depth of flavor to anything it touches. While it’s usually added to seafood dishes or as a meat rub, when used with this brine, it adds an incredible dimension of flavor.
Trust me… you’re going to love it!
What is buttermilk?
Buttermilk is basically fermented milk. Traditionally, buttermilk was always the liquid leftover from after milk was churned to make butter.
Thinner than milk and without the fat, yet retaining that delicious sweetness, the cultures in buttermilk means it stays good for longer than milk.
Nowadays, instead of being a by-product of the milk-churning butter-making process, buttermilk is purposely made. Modern dairies add cultures to fresh pasteurized milk to create buttermilk.
What does buttermilk do to a brine?
Buttermilk marinated turkey is wonderfully tender and incredibly delicious! Whether it’s a Thanksgiving turkey or a Christmas turkey, you want it to be special. Well, brining your turkey in buttermilk is the way to go.
When you brine turkey, you help the whole turkey retain its juices – from the turkey legs and the turkey breast to the wings and every other part.
Turkey is a naturally lean meat, which means it can easily end up very dry and tasteless during the roasting process, especially if you don’t get the preparation and cooking time correct.
Brining helps to keep everything succulent and juicy. Even if you go a little over the correct cooking time, a buttermilk brined turkey tends to come out perfectly juicy and tender.
This is, in large part, down to the saltiness, acidity and the sweetness of the buttermilk mixture. The acid in the buttermilk ‘denatures’ and ‘unravels’ the protein fibres in the meat. When they reconnect, they trap moisture within the meat.
Meanwhile, the salt in the brine gets into the cells of the meat through osmosis, while the sweetness of the buttermilk keeps the balance of flavor.
What type of turkey is best for brining with buttermilk?
Any type of standard supermarket turkey or a normal butcher’s turkey should be fine.
There’s one very important thing to bear in mind when brining a turkey. Any turkey that is labelled ‘kosher’ or has been pre-flavored should not be brined. This is because your turkey will end up far too salty.
This brine, aside from keeping the inside of your turkey wonderfully tender, will add a lot of seasoning. Therefore, it’s vital not to add a brine seasoning to a turkey that has already been salted.
You can also brine a frozen turkey in buttermilk. Just place the turkey in the buttermilk mixture and defrost it and brine it at the same time. Whether it’s partially or fully frozen, it still works.
How long can you leave turkey marinating?
For a whole turkey, you need at least 12 hours and anywhere up to 48 hours. Bringing turkey breast could be anything from 12 to 24 hours.
Is three days too long to brine a turkey?
Yes, it’s too long to brine a turkey for three days. You don’t need to brine a turkey for any longer than 48 hours.
Can you brine with milk?
to brine turkey. One other thing to note is that buttermilk lasts longer than milk and is easier to keep fresh, which makes it ideal for brining.
Can you make gravy from a buttermilk brined turkey?
When you brine a turkey, in buttermilk or any other type of brine, the pan juices in the roasting pan end up very salty.
So, if you’re planning on using the roasting pan drippings to make gravy after roasting a buttermilk brined turkey, be sure to have a taste first, otherwise you’ll end up with a gravy that is far too salty.
What else can I add to this brine?
Add any of the following to your brine, to get an extra dimension of flavor:
- Fresh rosemary
- Fresh thyme
- Bay leaves
- Cayenne pepper
- Ground ginger
- Juniper berries
- Coriander seeds
- Fennel seeds
- Fenugreek seeds
- Black peppercorns
- Lemon peel
- Orange peel
Tips for a perfect buttermilk brine
Make sure the brine has cooled completely
Adding raw poultry to warm brine is a recipe for disaster. Whether it’s a fresh turkey, a frozen turkey or a thawed frozen turkey, make sure you add it to a completely cooled brine.
Use kosher salt
Don’t use any other salt than kosher salt. A lot less salty than standard sea salt and a lot coarser, when brinin it’s the only way to go.
More brining recipes
Brining is a fantastic way to lock in the tenderness of meat and add to the flavor and texture. Here are a few more brining recipes for you to try:
- Whole turkey brine – when it comes to making a holiday turkey, this simple brining recipe is a winner
- Apple cider brine – bring some extra flavor to your turkey with this fantastic apple cider brine
- Brined chicken thighs – an easy way to inject some next level flavor into your chicken thighs
- Brined chicken drumsticks – don’t stop at thighs… try these drumsticks on for size!
More Christmas and thanksgiving favorites
Need some more holiday season inspiration? Here are a few traditional classics to get you in the festive mood:
- Whole roast turkey – the magnificent centerpiece to your Thanksgiving or Christmas feast. Of course, your festive turkey should be as good as you can get it and this recipe more than delivers the goods, with a succulent, tender turkey that impresses every single time
- Turkey giblet broth – a wonderful stock, this turkey giblet broth proves once and for all that you should never throw away turkey gilets. Packed to the brim with rich, deep flavor and fantastically simple, this is a broth recipe that works to add depth to so many different dishes
- Turkey giblet gravy – use your broth to make this incredible gravy. Deep and rich in flavor, it’s set to become a firm family favorite
- Marmite roast potatoes – this crispy yet fluffy roast potatoes are delectable! The star of the show is the favourite flavor enhancer, the British ingredient Marmite. If you’ve never tasted marmite roast potatoes, you’re in for a treat
- Apricot stuffing – a tasty vegetarian stuffing with lots of flavor. It’s fruity, with a savory depth that makes for a delicious side