Simmered Fresh Tomato Sauce

Simmered Fresh Tomato Sauce

One thing that never ceases to amaze me is how easily tomatoes grow here in the UK. For four years in a row we’ve had bumper crops of tomatoes. With Gabriel’s arrival this year our vegetable plot got grossly neglected and our poor tomatoes missed out on the tender loving care they needed. Yet we harvested kilos of them ever week. There was a slight problem though, I didn’t know what to do with them! I needed a solution quick. It would have been an awful shame to let premium quality organic tomatoes go to waste.

My main problem with cooked tomatoes is that they are just so acidic. After flinching I would usually add a few teaspoons of sugar to temper them. However, I decided to live life dangerously and make a fresh tomato sauce. After submerging the red beauties in boiling water for a while, I patiently skinned all twenty-eight of them. It didn’t take too long and Pluji kept me company (read she was in beg-mode barely restraining herself to practise the pathetic lift-one-paw technique). Afterwards she gratefully polished off the tomato skins while Shacia watched her – probably thinking Pluji’s one mad dog. The sauce started off as very watery, but as time passed the water started to evaporate in the simmering process. Every now and then I checked up on the sauce, giving it a gentle stir. After ninety minutes all that remained was the thick essence of tomatoes and a strong, sweet aroma in the air. Slowly I dared to taste it while eyeing the can of sugar nearby. Tangy, but yet so sweet. I was amazed. When Neil tasted it he asked whether I added sugar to the sauce. I nearly chased him out of the kitchen with my rolling pin for knowing my cooking so well. Nonetheless I was very pleased with the outcome of the experiment. All the tomatoes following this batch have met their fate the same way. So moreish indeed.

There is a secret to this recipe. Wait for the tomatoes to ripen properly. Keep them out of the fridge and stash them with other fruit. Admire how they change colour from a light red to the deepest red possible. Squeeze them gently. They should be slightly soft, yet firm. Your fingernail should leave a slight indentation in the skin. It might seem like a lot of work at first, but if the tomatoes are really ripe peeling them would be a breeze since the skin slips off the flesh easily. I can assure you it is well worth the effort.

P.S. I am submitting this recipe to Andrea‘s Grow Your Own monthly food blogging event.

Simmered Fresh Tomato Sauce
Serves 3
Preparation: 15 mins – Cooking: 1hr 35 mins
Suitable for freezing

Simmered Fresh Tomato Sauce

  • 1kg (2 lb) fresh tomatoes
  • 15ml (1tbsp) olive oil
  • 1 onion, peeled and chopped
  • 3 garlic cloves, peeled and crushed
  • brown sugar
  • salt and freshly milled black pepper
  1. Put the tomatoes in a big bowl. Pour boiling water over the tomatoes until every one is submerged. After a few minutes drain the tomatoes and hold them under running cold water. Slips their skins off.
  2. Heat the oil in a medium saucepan, then add the onion and garlic and let them gently cook for 5-6 minutes, until they are softened and golden. Now add the tomatoes. Simmer the tomatoes on a very low heat, without a lid for 1½ hours or until all the liquid had evaporated and the tomatoes are reduced to a thick, jam-like consistency, stirring now and then.
  3. Add salt and pepper to taste.
  4. If the sauce if extremely acidic, you can try adding brown sugar in teaspoon increments until you’re satisfied.
  5. Serve the sauce spooned over pasta, sprinkled with Parmesan.
Serving Suggestion
  • If you like mozzarella cheese, you can melt some in the sauce before serving up.
  • For extra flavour you can add some torn fresh basil leaves to the sauce before serving.

Become A Greedy Gourmet

Join thousands of hungry readers who keep coming back for more. Whether you're a passionate cook or rather prefer to travel and try out restaurants, there is a newsletter for you - just take your pick. Or subscribe to both!

We respect your email privacy

Powered by AWeber Autoresponder


  1. Robyn says

    This was a great recipe to try – simple yet effective if you dont have time to constantly be cooking if your busy!! Will definitely be making this again :)

  2. says

    Robyn – Indeed. Just give it a stir every now and then and voila you can sit down for a scrumptious meal!

    Andrea – It’s great! This is definitely one of the big discoveries I made this year.

  3. says

    Sheila: This recipe is so delicious it won’t last more than a day in your household! :-) I have no idea if it freezes well but I don’t see why it wouldn’t. Please do let me know how you get on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *